This game, similar to Perfection, involved quickly fitting puzzle pieces into a board before a timer ran out. It was popular in the 1980s and 1990s.
There were a few other games with a similar concept, so if "Puzzle Mania" isn't ringing a bell, you could also be thinking of:
* "Jumble" - This game involved arranging jumbled letters into words.
* "Brain Teaser" - This game, from Milton Bradley, had a similar theme to "Puzzle Mania".
Let me know if any of these sound right! If you have more details about the game you're looking for, I can try to be more specific.