Instructions
Choose a pin to push up with your controller. Scroll to the pin using the arrows and situate the lock pick below the pin.
Time your moves carefully to successfully pick the lock. Press up on the pin and hit "X" at the exact moment the pin touches the top of the lock. Listen for a double-clicking noise. This will indicate the exact moment at which you should hit "X."
Push all the pins up with this technique until the lock opens. If one pin falls, your pick will break and they will all fall. When this happens you must restart the process.