Things You'll Need
Instructions
Check the condition of both stones under your jeweler's loup. Although sapphires and diamonds are both extremely hard, sapphires also have a tendency to brittleness, so you might possibly see the occasional minute chip in a green sapphire.
Rotate both stones under the loupe. Unlike diamonds, sapphires show a pronounced dichroism. This is when the color within the stone seems to change according to the angle from which you view it. A colored diamond will not display this effect.
Look next to see how well both stones reflect the light. The technical term for this is dispersion, but jewelers refer to it as 'fire.' Although effect of dispersion is muted in colored stones, a green diamond should still show more fire than a green sapphire.
A diamond will scratch a sapphire, however a sapphire will be unable to scratch a diamond.