Instructions
Start with the obvious place--cigar stores. While mostly done away with, some shops may still have a wooden Indian inside as an aesthetic tribute to days of old. Of course, getting the proprietor to part with the item may prove to be a difficult and expensive endeavor.
Shop around antique stores and consignment shops. Again, this may be an expensive avenue, as the popularity of the cigar store Indian peaked in the late 19th century.
Shop online. There are a variety of websites that offer hand-carved wood crafts, including cigar store Indians. They vary in height, detail and price, but it will not be nearly as pricey as shopping for the real McCoy.
Barter with traders. Avid collectors sometimes have their own websites devoted to offering finders fees and such for authentic cigar store Indians. Only through direct communication will you be able to find out if the collector is willing to part with any of his prizes.
Shop online auction sites, especially those that auction antiques and collectibles. This may be the quickest way to find out what is available for purchase.