Different Animals
Pin the Tail on the Donkey can easily be substituted with any other animal with a tail. Use an image of an animal that is a particular favorite with the guest of honor. For example, use a pig with a squiggly tail or a bunny with a fluffy tail.
Baby Shower Version
If you're coming up with a game for a baby shower, create a unique version of Pin the Tail on the Donkey. Use a cartoon image of a baby and another item like a bow or bottle to "pin" on the baby. You can even use a diaper pin as the pin for the game.
Team Version
Make an alternative Pin the Tail on the Donkey game by playing in teams. Blindfold one player and place the paper donkey somewhere in the room. The other teammates can give vocal directions to alert the blindfolded player to the donkey̵7;s location.
Pin Alternatives
If little ones are playing the game, use an alternative to a pin or tack. Items like tape or magnets will hold the tail to the donkey, avoiding the threat of pricked fingers. If using magnets, make sure the paper donkey is taped to something magnetic.