Four Leaf Clover
A four leafed clover is a difficult item to find in any neighborhood, and possibly no one will find one. To make it more fun, allow the kids to make an item from other things or draw a picture of the item if they can't find it.
Feather
A feather should be an easy item to find, but it may be difficult. It could be a feather from a bird, from a feather duster or from a boa.
Rubber Duck
Rubber ducks are sometimes found in the bathroom of families with small children. However, not every household owns one, so this may be a more difficult item to collect.
Basketball
This is an easy item to find in most neighborhoods. If they can't find a real basketball, kids can use an orange balloon with black lines, or a basketball player poster.
Yearbook
Yearbooks are collected by many families and should be an easy item to find. Make sure that the kids ask permission before taking this item out of the house.
Rubber Bands
Rubber bands are simple items, but it can be difficult to find one when it is needed.
Picture of the State Flag
Some kids don't know what their state flag looks like so this item can provide a learning experience. Kids will have to look up what it looks like, and either find one or draw a picture of one.