Nun's Habit
One gag gift that never disappoints is the nun's habit costume. Typically, this gag gift is given to someone who doesn't necessarily represent the virtues of most nuns. Perhaps someone who uses foul language, or is known to overindulge in certain kinds of beverages. And, of course, there is always the option to give the nun's habit to a man.
Jesus Is Coming Bumper Sticker
A traditional church party favorite, the bumper sticker reads "Jesus is coming. Look busy." Perfect for staff workers at the church, or even the priest, minister or altar people. The sticker can even be applied to people's cars while they're at the party.
Inflatable Sandals
A huge hit for any church occasion, a gag gift of inflatable sandals that look like those worn by Jesus will liven up any party. The recipient is able to take off his or her shoes that were worn to the party, blow up the sandals, and wear them around the party. Highly visual and immensely entertaining, inflatable sandals are an excellent, affordable gag gift for church occasions.
"Let My People Go" Toilet-Seat Cover
Bathroom humor is always effective at parties. A church occasion is no exception. This gag gift is a toilet-seat cover made to resemble matzoh, the traditional holy bread, and is emblazoned with the words "Let my people go." This phrase is an obvious play on words, comparing the notion of religious freedom with the need to relieve oneself.