Clarity
Clarity is a primary concern when choosing a cushion-cut stone because the larger facets of this type of cut make inclusions more visible. Choose a diamond that is a minimum of SI2 on the diamond clarity scale. A rating of SI2 ensures that only slight inclusions are visible with the naked eye. If a cushion-cut diamond is graded lower in clarity, the inclusions can be quite prominent due to the larger facets.
Color
Since its facets do not create the brilliance associated with many other diamond cuts, color is the second most important characteristic of a cushion-cut diamond. There will not be as much sparkle and fire to disguise or distract from a lower-colored stone. If you want the diamond to appear white, the color grade of the cushion-cut diamond should ideally be no lower than the G to I range. Diamonds graded G through I are nearly colorless to the untrained, naked eye. The only stones with less color are graded D through F.
Carat
Smaller cushion-cut diamonds are difficult to find, as the large planes and facets are better obtained when cutting a larger stone. To fully appreciate the faceting pattern of a cushion-cut diamond, choose one that is no smaller than three-fourths of a carat. Any smaller and it will be harder to appreciate the unique character of your stone's cut.
Cut
The measurements of a cushion-cut diamond vary from stone to stone. Some may be more rectangular, others are more square. Even the experts cannot agree on the optimal ratio of a cushion-cut diamond's length to its width. The Diamond Buying Guide recommends a cushion-cut diamond that features a length-to-width ratio of 1.20 to 1.30, while Blue Nile advocates a length-to-width ratio of 1.0 to 1.05. The ratio is a matter of personal preference, but be sure to choose a diamond with a cut quality grade of no less than "Good." Any lower and your diamond will not reflect light to its fullest potential.