Things You'll Need
Instructions
Place your silly putty in a mixing bowl. The original dull pink-colored silly putty works best for colorizing, as it is the product's natural color.
Add two or three drops of food coloring into the bowl. You can always add more coloring later if these few drops don't create a dark enough shade.
Put on latex gloves. Food coloring is not harmful to your skin, but it can temporarily stain your fingers.
Knead the Silly Putty, working the color into the putty. It will take several minutes for the food coloring saturate the Silly Putty.
Set the Silly Putty on a wax paper overnight, letting the food coloring dry. After the food coloring's liquid evaporates overnight, the color pigment stays behind on the Silly Putty.