Things You'll Need
Instructions
Buy a holly seed from Costolot's General Store for seven coins. If you do not want to grow your own holly bush, you can also buy a holly berry for 30 coins.
Plant the holly seed on a patch of dirt or snow. Holly seeds do not sprout in grass. Give the seed some water and wait for it to grow. This takes about two in-game days.
Wait for the holly bush to mature and form berries. Hit the bush to knock off berries or wait for them to drop.
Go to Bart's Exchange. Select one of the holly berries as the object for Bart to transform. Select his bronze, silver or gold tinkering package. If you choose the bronze package for 15 coins, Bart has a 60 percent chance of successfully changing a holly berry into figgy pudding. The 52-coin silver package gives an 85 percent chance and the 300-coin gold package has a 100 percent success rate.
Wait for Bart to tinker the holly berry. If his tinkering succeeds, the berry turns into a bowl of figgy pudding.