Instructions
Raise your gardening level. An Arocknid appears at Gardening Level 6, and an Eaglair appears at Level 33. Other pinatas appear at different level milestones.
Plant flowers, bushes, trees and vegetables to attract pinatas. A Bunnycomb appears if you have a carrot in the garden, a Buzzlegum arrives if you have two or more buttercups and a Taffly appears when you have any flower in the garden. Plant each new type of seed you receive from Seedos to attract new species.
Keep a variety of pinatas in your garden, as some pinatas are attracted by others. A Jameleon appears when you have Flutterscotches in three different colors, and a Buzzenge arrives if you have at least one Candary.
Change the terrain of your garden, adding long grass or digging ponds. A Newtgat appears when 2 percent of your garden is water, and a Syrupent appears when 1 percent of your garden is grass.
Visit Petula's Paper Pets shop in the village to buy domestic pinatas like the Kittyfloss and Barkbark. Domestic pinatas don't appear in your garden on their own.
Tame sour pinatas to make them resident. Highlight a sour pinata, like a Sour Bonboon or Sour Shellybean, and press the "Y" button to learn how to tame it.